Reviews and Comments

Carson Chittom

carson@books.chittom.family

Joined 4 months ago

I have very specific, if subjective, meanings for book ratings.

⭐: I did not finish this, or wouldn't start it. ⭐⭐: I finished this, but I sort of regret it. ⭐⭐⭐: I don't regret finishing this, but I'll probably never read it again. ⭐⭐⭐⭐: It's likely I will reread this. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐: I want to own this to read whenever the mood strikes, because I'll definitely reread it.

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed Too Many Cooks by Rex Stout (Nero Wolfe, #5)

Rex Stout: Too Many Cooks (EBook, 2010, Bantam) 3 stars

Nero Wolfe leaves his Manhattan brownstone to travel to the resort of Kanawha Spa, in …

Not one of the best

3 stars

You can absolutely tell that this book was published in 1938. It is not one of Stout's best.

Part of Stout's aim here was undoubtedly to highlight for his readers the way racial prejudice operated in the American South in the late 1930s. Despite this good intention, I don't feel like those sections really stand up very well in terms of story. (Having a luxury spa in 30s West Virginia seems a little forced, for starters.)

Stout's characterization of the victim's wife is straight out of femme fatale noir.

For those who wish to totally avoid racial slurs: this book does contain them. They are to the best of my recollection "appropriately" used—I mean the characters who use them would use them—and Nero Wolfe does not.

Still, in my opinion even "not the best" Nero Wolfe stories are worth reading. But maybe just move on to the next one when …

commented on The Red Box by Rex Stout (Nero Wolfe, #4)

Rex Stout, Carolyn G. Hart: The Red Box (EBook, 2011, Crimeline) No rating

From Wikipedia: "I never knew a plaguier case. We have all the knowledge we need, …

The main female character, Helen Frost, says in answer to a question from Nero Wolfe that she'll "be twenty-one in May." Given that this was published in 1937, that would make her just over 108 now, if she were a real person.